In the calm Amish country of Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, an unthinkable crime emerges when a dead infant is found on an Amish farm. The finger of suspicion points to Katie Fisher, an unmarried 18-year-old Amish girl, who denies the claim despite medical evidence. Enter Ellie Hathaway, a high-profile defense attorney from Philadelphia seeking a retreat from her demanding career. Rather than finding solitude, Ellie is drawn into Katie's case, confronting the vast cultural divide between her own world and the Amish community - a divide she must bridge to defend her client. As she takes on a system of justice starkly different from what she knows, Ellie embarks on a journey that challenges her professional acumen and personal beliefs, unearthing the strength of familial bonds and the weight of hidden truths.