Three years following the Virgil County High School massacre, the story of Sarah's final moments is widely known: a tale of faith boldly proclaimed as her life was cut tragically short. Yet the narration of her martyrdom diverges sharply from reality—a fact only Lee, her best friend, and a handful of survivors can truthfully attest. In the shadows of a grief-stricken community and the looming release of a book penned by Sarah's parents, Lee grapples with the weighty dilemma of whether to unveil her contradictory narrative. As the survivors each harbor their distinct versions of that fateful day, Lee stands at the crossroads of silence and truth, with the outcomes of each path shrouded in potential distress and backlash. Her resolve is further tested as she uncovers deeper complexities surrounding the cherished myth of Sarah's end and confronts the moral intricacies of exposing the unvarnished truth.